breakaway[def] from Upper-midClass #w1r2

See also

Q: Why is it crucial for me to break away from the Chinese upper-middle-class mainstream in the U.S. ?
A: My asset and esp. combined salary is lower-middle-class. My carefree ezlife demands that I live well within (hopefully below) my means.
A: if I follow herd instinct, and surrender to that peer pressure,

  • my Melvin3 total burden would balloon to $7-8k, so my total burn rate could exceed 10k/M. I think this burn rate is top 2% of U.S. households.
  • I would lose my cash-flow high ground (brbr, Fuller wealth, FCF,,) My CPF + rental income + Beijing inheritance … all become 杯水車薪.
  • I would lose my steadfast focus on the long-term important/non-urgent goals of healthy longevity, career longevity, family harmony, ..
  • I would long for an additional USD 2M in net asset (endless greed). These Chinese middle-class families typically have a net asset of $1M+ but have a thin brbr. They don’t seem to live within their means.
  • I would be pressured to maintaining my salary and worry about job loss. I would envy those fake role models [interview rock stars, OC-effective guys, ]
  • Such a self-created baggage is simply too heavy. Something’s gotta give.

— t_breakAway tag is not about my own “unique or original” solutions.

It’s more about questioning,  challenging, rejecting and letting go of the Chinese middle-class immigrant mentality.

It’s related to t_mellow,

[21]Y livelihood pressure@USD300k/Y income #LZ.Yu

Yet another blogpost on a familiar paradox, after a discussion, without a lot of new content. I wrote this letter to my wife, but edited later.

Over a 2021 Chinese New Year dinner, I described the paradox “Many WallSt colleagues have a household income around USD 300k (USD 17k/M after tax), in the top 2% among U.S. households, but I notice some kind of livelihood pressure.” (The paradox also exists in Singapore.) I asked why.

  • LZ.Yu and his wife pointed out the car cost, mortgage cost, private schools, tuitions (more expensive in U.S.), perhaps maid cost.
  • LZ.Yu also pointed out taxes including pTax and the tax-like med insurance (Melvin3 items)
  • I pointed out the FOMO factor — they spend as much as other families in that tax bracket, otherwise they felt impoverished. The Chinese middle class tend to complain about livelihood pressure while living in the top 2% of tax brackets. See [19]wage+homePrice: biased views@China colleagues etc.
  • I pointed out their need to save up for an Ivy League education .. about USD 600k for 2 kids. Real pressure.

If you earn $17k a month, and spend $16k, with close to no zero net balance in the bank (below 10k), you have a very thin buffer (brbr). You would feel a livelihood pressure, whether you admit it or not.

LZ.Yu’s wife has a familiar view — “For a big spender, it’s her own money. If she earns it herself, and if she is happy with her lifestyle and if she can cope with it over ups and downs, then it’s suitable for her“.  This view is full of IF’s. In reality, millions of people spend like there’s no tomorrow. When tomorrow comes, they would not show regret in public, but in their quiet moments, they would feel regret once a while, esp. when they look at their saver-investor peers. Same regret as binge-eating, binge-gaming or binge-drinking. We do regret later .. our life was weakened not enriched.

My first-hand observation of my high-earning sibling (before his/her mortgage) showed me that any savings built up in bank account tend to disappear within months. I think it’s a lack of self-discipline. Similarly, you also said some homeless people have trouble saving away a windfall income. I think even if this person receives a million-dollar inheritance, he would spend it all within 2 years.  A common pattern among undisciplined people.

Note the absence of “pressure” in that big-spender lifestyle as described, but I believe the limited level of savings makes the lifestyle rather vulnerable. Indeed LZ.Yu’s wife went on to describe a big-spender’s reaction to a $1k denied medical claim.

[21]become as WellOff as]SG@@ #war-chest

See also [17]U.S.burn rate now n after #Gerald

“Well off” is a vague term. “Carefree ezlife” is slightly less vague.  This blogpost is focused on their intersection.

In several blogposts, I have highlighted the high maintenance when living in U.S. , which disrupts my carefree ezlife. I have also highlighted the additional costs such as Melvin3.

Q: is there any hope of feeling well-off as I now feel in Singapore?
A: yes, though much smaller than in SG.

First, the key ingredients of my well-off life in Singapore:

  1. brbr
  2. job (and salary) security
  3. no strain due to long commute.. Such a strain makes me feel impoverished
  4. very cheap medbx
  5. no mtg, negligible pTax
  6. no car needed
  7. wife can afford to stay home and take care of kids’ studies etc
  8. ? no private tuition at the moment .. a small factor
  9. ? rental income ?  no effect on my life now

Q: how could I realistically become well-off in the U.S. ?
A: would take a lot of effort, accumulation, from now

  • #1) We need to accept (tough!) a more minimalist lifestyle than my cohort and Aim at a burn rate 10% lower. Remember they have much higher household income. Resist FOMO and lifestyle creep, just like in Singapore.
  • initially no car. Then buy a modest (but safe) car and use it less than U.S. families.
  • initially buy medbx for wife+kids. Later can include me on a cheap medbx with high deductible + coinsurance
  • reduce restaurant visits
  • work hard and slowly on the 43R model, rather than raising my salary. If I remain in-demand, then my salary would be reasonable. Marginal gain in salary requires extraordinary marginal effort.
  • rEstate is one domain where U.S. offers advantages over SG, and may present the best route to ffree
  • avoid overseas vacations. U.S. + Canada + Mexico offer plenty of choices.
  • one of the new strategies is the war chest .. section below

— war chest .. build up a much bigger war chest than I need in Singapore. This is the definition of war chest. This is also a battery that can store excess solar energy. These “batteries” are also war chests, but not all financial.

Analog: covid19 required Singapore government to massively strengthen its pandemic capacity. SG gov past reserve is a classic war chest

 

WMT/TGT: car-dependency livelihood@@

k_X_car_dependency

If you are used to car dependency and now I ask you to imagine a life without private car (but with car sharing, occasionally car rental etc…) you will think of many challenges. One of them is the lost convenience of Walmart, or Target. These are two of the several superstores that I have used. Look at the alternative solutions — they provide for most of the situations including some special situations.

Therefore, car-free living in a city underserved by Walmart may sound like a livelihood issue, but it is not really. I lived in East Orange, Porter Square, Boston, Brooklyn for years without any of these superstores nearby.

— alternative: similar stores on my commute and on our Chinese grocery shopping trips .. These trips are likely to pass by several shopping districts.

— alternative: smaller stores within biking distance
The superstores are sometimes located beyond my bike access in some suburban cities. I seldom choose to live in those rural cities. If I do, then there are always smaller (still sizeable) stores near my home, though price could be slightly higher.

I can go to nearby shops and big stores for most of my needs, and reduce Walmart trip to one weekend per month.

— alternative: planning for scheduled trips .. in https://tanbinvest.dreamhosters.com/wp-admin/post.php?post=21798&action=edit one American author said “I have started making this trip once a month. During the month I will make a list so that I will remember what I need”

— alternative: online shopping … can be cheaper and simpler. I just don’t know when I would start using it. I did go online to buy laptops, pills, baby powder, chia, batteries…. Good return policy.

— price tag .. Walmart is known for low price. Target is slightly higher but still affordable. The big warehouse stores [BJ’s / Costco / Sam’s ] are even cheaper.  So without a car, is our burn rate going to be higher? No.

  • reason 1: we save on car related costs.
  • reason : In fact, in the U.S. mass-produced goods are very economical and competitively priced compared to human service including restaurants, repairs, lawyers,,,
  • reason : online price is even lower most of the time.

##relocation war-chest #H.Yin

Some of the content below are irrelevant to you, but I think many people like personal stories (or personal observations).

OK I told you about the “limited government support to ordinary Americans in the middle tier”, i.e. lower-middle-class or below. Now, for most techies on Wall St (or West coast, which is beyond the Bay area), I think pretax household income exceeds USD 200k, perhaps well above 25th percentile nationally. That would place us above the American middle tier. In this email, I want to shift focus away from “us”, and look at the ordinary Americans. My point is

Singapore government provides a lot of essentials for the middle tier. In contrast, ordinary, middle-tier Americans must fend for themselves on many fronts:

  1. power failures .. U.S. has decent infrastructure, but bad weather can cause power failures. Majority of the Americans I know keep a contingency power generator at home. In Singapore, you can rely on your government rather than your generator.
  2. snow clearance .. After heavy snow U.S. landed home owners must clear piles of snow on their driveway and sidewalk, otherwise they can’t get out of the house. If you can’t physically do it, then I don’t know if you can call a contractor, but the local government won’t do it for you 🙁
  3. sidewalk maintenance .. (similar to snow clearance.) Any damage, pothole, pests … are either left untreated for a long time or a resident has to engage a private contractor. The local government may not have sufficient budget for it. Compared to sidewalks, road maintenance is more likely to be taken up by government.
  4. security cameras in public places .. often for-display only. In Singapore, these cameras are usually functional.
  5. clean tap water .. Singapore government is outstanding in providing clean tap water that’s guaranteed safe to drink. I drink it every day. In contrast, every American family I know buys bottled water every week, because few would drink from the tap.
  6. sports facilities .. Singapore government is outstanding in providing free stadiums and low-cost public swimming/gym facilities (up to $2.50 per entry), in additional to small exercise corners. U.S. swimming pools are about 100 times more expensive. I have never heard of public gyms (stadiums… seldom) provided by a local government, so I think that stadiums are usually part of a school, and gyms are always commercial. Running cost of swimming pools and gyms are higher than stadiums so government needs a sizeable buget.
  7. library .. Same situation as sports facilites. Public libraries are few and much smaller in the U.S. than in Singapore. Low-income families must find other means, like donations, friends, school library, or pre-owned books sold on Amazon. Reason? Local governments have limited funding.
  8. childcare .. Ordinary Singapore citizens can send young kids to subsidized pre-schools.. about SGD 400/M after government subsidy. I don’t think such a low price is available in the tristate area. The last time I checked (2010), it cost more than USD 1000/M. Singapore government-linked operators run many of those subsidized pre-schools, but U.S. government doesn’t.
  9. counseling support for divorcing couples, kids from broken families, and families with special needs……. I don’t have statistics, but I think the Singapore government has a higher budget per thousand residents. My family has received SG government-funded support. My friends in the U.S. also need such support but had to wait longer. If you need such help in the U.S. and can afford it, you should definitely seek professional counselors. I think 2/3 of families need this support at least once in 10 years.
  10. financial education/counselling/planning .. Many ordinary people postpone or neglect financial planning due to lack of education. Since 2008 GFC, Singapore government has asked all retail-facing financial institutions (insurers, banks…) to waive consultation fees for retail customers who don’t end up buying. I often have hour-long conversations in person with these consultants. No such free consultation in the U.S. The less-educated lay public must teach themselves and ask friends or pay a consultant for advice.
  11. personal credit data /governance/ .. U.S. system can be messy (personal experience). I feel U.S. government is not doing its job in this area. In Singapore, if you notice an incorrect credit record, you can call the lender or escalate to the authorities, since all retail lenders are regulated by government. U.S. authorities aren’t involved, so you must liaise with the three private credit bureaus. They might give you some basic tips and redirect you to various private companies. If you are well-off, there are consultants to help you, according to hearsay.
  12. car ownership .. I think most of the U.S. middle tier households needs a car. DMV (department of motor vehicles) is very slow and inefficient in most places, presumably due to government funding. I don’t like driving so I never bought a car. I can only guess — Car repairs, insurance, police engagement are all complicated, presumably more complicated than in Singapore. Ordinary Singaporeans don’t have to own a car (personal experience) thanks to public transport. No U.S. city government offers such an extensive public transport.
  13. public transport .. when provided, are infrequent, (much) older, more prone to breakdowns compared to Singapore, based on my experience in NY and NJ. I used subway, commuter trains and buses. Given the limitations, you may still need a car even if you live in New York City. On weekends, up to half the NYC subway lines are unavailable.
  14. condo HOA .. (for those living in condominiums) I have never paid a condo fee in Singapore or the U.S. but I suspect HOA-to-valuation ratio is much higher in the U.S. than Singapore, due to maintenance costs, physical security and other labor costs. Again, I think the government doesn’t do enough in the U.S. so your condo committee have to step in as a quasi-government. Most middle-tier Singaporeans don’t pay condo fees at all, since they mostly live in HDB.
  15. repair cost .. be it vehicles, appliances, buildings … these costs are all higher in the U.S. than Singapore (Singapore is not cheap!). Culprit is labor cost. Trained technicians cost more in the U.S. (not government’s fault). Now, most homes in the U.S. are wood constructions by private developers, inhabited for up to 100Y. As such they require significantly more repairs. In contrast, HDB builds more reliable, newer, concrete homes that require less repair. Also, Singapore government takes care of some major repairs free of charge (personal experience). If you look at the repairs for public infrastructure (roads, rail roads, buses, government buildings/vehicles,,,) you may notice a stark contrast. There repairs are faster in Singapore, probably due to adequate budget + cheaper labor, as private contractors employ mostly work-permit holders, which help SG public infrastructure cost control.
  16. tax rules .. too complicated for ordinary people. Many Americans living below the median household income (50% of U.S. population) struggle to understand the intricacies but don’t want to pay $200/year for a tax consultant. As a result, they might be over-taxed by thousands of dollars (not a fraud, but a failure to optimize filing). In contrast, Singapore tax rate and tax rules are more “friendly” to ordinary residents, so we don’t struggle or need to pay consultants. I actually called the tax department in U.S. and in Singapore many times … vastly different user experience. Reason? U.S. tax department is underfunded and under-staffed to provide useful assistance, and the system is convoluted.
  17. immigration support .. Both countries have a high percentage of their residents being immigrants. I dealt with immigration headaches in both systems. U.S. system is far more convoluted. I called immigration departments many times. U.S. hotline is very hard to use. I had to engage consultants (lawyers). Again, I think Singapore government built a simpler, more usable system, so that ordinary people can resolve their issues without paying a consultant.
  18. .. Related topic… If you or your kids have issues with U.S. passport, SSN, identify theft, or birth record, again you face a complicated system. If you call the government department, then you will depend on your luck. Will you find a knowledgeable officer… get bounced from department to department .. face lengthy delays? If you are well-off, you might want to try finding an advisor, perhaps through your employer. Singapore system is straightforward.
  19. legal system .. too complicated. Offenses, commercial disputes, immigration, traffic/driving, tenancy,,,, Few lay people can handle legal issue without lawyers. Legal issues can take lots of time, anxiety and legwork. Low-income Americans are unlucky. Singapore legal system is less complicated. You can call several public hotlines to get some basic help. There is probably less pro-bono assistance in the U.S. than in Singapore (personal experience), but this not U.S. government’s fault.
  20. medical .. (including health insurance) is the most obvious example of a dysfunctional government failing to provide for tax payers. U.S. employers often step in to provide for the staff. SG government runs very affordable polyclinics in the HDB heartlands (within a few minutes of bus ride). Public hospitals are also affordable.
  21. Health insurance .. CPF Medishield costs a fraction of the typical U.S. insurance premiums, though Medishield covers only hospitalization.

Considering all of the above, I allocate USD 200k for my family relocation (excluding home/car purchase). It is a war chest.

expensive cars breed unhealthy over-usage #driveway

k_X_car_dependency

Quality of life is correlated with more walking/cycling, less driving. FIRE bloggers frequently advocate living close to work and minimize car usage.

Owning an expensive car makes you want to drive it more, and walk less .. lower quality of life.

In G3top articles@car-free liv`]U.S.#w1r2, the American author said

With that beast sitting in my driveway, I often felt this anxious need to go out and do something: run errands, pick up groceries, etc. etc. I was like a child with a pair of scissors in my hands: you just want to use it. Once it was gone, I kind of felt lighter. I no longer felt the pressure to get out of the house and do something simply because the car was sitting there. I have thus consolidated my trips.

xp: I feel the same about my foot massager, my back massager, my puch-bag, my spectacles … The more you have spent in terms of money and time, the heavier this pressure. The more expensive your car is, the worse you would feel leaving it underutilized in the garage 95% of the time. Rental car is expensive but worth considering.

  • The fancy electronics in the car could become outdated and worth-less after 5 years.
  • some replacement parts may become hard to find when they reach end of life defined by the manufacturer.
  • Prolonged disuse can cause slow damage to some mechanical parts.